Graded Card Set

[delbert1981]

I'm putting together a small set of 10-12 graded cards. For display and potential resell down the road is it better to have all the cards graded by the same company, PSA or SGC, or is a mixture of both ok? Does it even matter?
Thanks for your opinions. I've not started yet so I appreciate your input before I begin.

[toledo_mudhen]

It would matter - to me anyway.

What era of cards -

if Vintage I would prefer all SGC just because of the Black Frame in slab

If modern then PSA may be the way to go

[delbert1981]

The set would be from the 60's

[parkplace33]

Whatever company you pick, recommend the same company for all the cards. I would not mix and match.

[delbert1981]

Thanks !!!

[jimmer77]

I too like to collect 50's and 60'' All Star sets and have them graded...I recently did the 68 Topps All Stars and used SGC, but yes I prefer Alllto be with the same TPG

[1880nonsports]

ONE grading company AND that the "grades" be at least somewhat consistent if your future aspiration is to sell the cards as a "set" - that is to say people usually gravitate to consistency.....

[Vintagedeputy]

SGC all the way.

[Leon]

I would do CSG or PSA...

.