Cards some collectors think are rare, but are not.

[ValKehl]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

This is exactly why Cobb and Wagner (among other prewar) cards are not over-valued even at recent high prices and why, I think, they have lots of room to grow further. For example, there are 67 total graded 1910 Tip Top Wagners on the combined SGC and PSA pop reports. That’s nothing. Only 67 people get to own one, assuming nobody has two!! Considering what a t206 Wagner goes for, and this is the closest thing to that, it should be a $200k card!

Ryan, the reason the 1910 Tip Top Wags isn't a $200K card is because there aren't all that many collectors of the Tip Top set (probably far less than 67).

[familytoad]

I don’t disagree that there are fewer Tip Top set collectors, but that’s a bit different than saying the Wagner itself isn’t collected at the same rate as any other highly regarded card.

Many collectors are ignoring sets in favor of singles from what I see.
I’d rather have the Wagner and forego the rest of the 1910 Tip Top set…

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Ryan, the reason the 1910 Tip Top Wags isn't a $200K card is because there aren't all that many collectors of the Tip Top set (probably far less than 67).