Some grading opinions please

[Delray Vintage]

I brought these two 1887 cards into the PSA booth at the National. One came back a 7 , one trimmed. Not sure if it was two different graders or same person. They have exactly the same size borders. Any opinions.

[HOF Auto Rookies]

You'll get much better replies with better pictures/scans. It's tough to tell with those images.

[glynparson]

Easier to see scans or at least much better pics. Can not tell anything from what you posted. That said size is not the best way to determine if something is trimmed.

[Delray Vintage]

Sorry the digital photos are bery sharp but did not download here well

[bnorth]

Crack the "trimmed" one out and send it back to PSA with the cards of a large submitter.

[JustinD]

Originally Posted by bnorth

Crack the "trimmed" one out and send it back to PSA with the cards of a large submitter.

bingo.

[glynparson]

I was doing at least a thousand cards a month for an extended period of time, i still submit large quantities and i wish half the BS i hear from people were true I'd have a lot more money. Easy to be a conspiracy theorists and spout garbage.

[bnorth]

Originally Posted by glynparson

I was doing at least a thousand cards a month for an extended period of time, i still submit large quantities and i wish half the BS i hear from people were true I'd have a lot more money. Easy to be a conspiracy theorists and spout garbage.

Yes Glyn with those #'s you would be considered a large submitter by me. Do you really believe you receive the same exact service/grades as the guy that submits a few cards a year? Have you ever bought 10 cards from one of their largest submitters and sent them in to see what you would get for grades, have you ever sent in one card on a small personal account and then sent in the same card again through a large submitter like yourself, I have and it is the reason I have the opinion I do.

Now onto something that is important, hope you are kicking the Lyme diseases butt Glyn
and feeling better.

[bigfish]

Resubmit the trimmed one. I predict a 7.5.

[JustinD]

Everyone can live and die by them as much as they want and I will not demean them for it.

In MY opinion the serial resubmitters for bumps, the numerous cased shady cards (including the most famous one they ever did) and even the recent thread with the board member sending back a damaged card that PSA doctored and recased is far more than enough info for me to place less trust than a 18 year old kid picking my daughter up in a cargo van with a bed in the back.