Pie Traynor cards and memorabilia are awesome

[rats60]

Originally Posted by bbcard1

I am not implying Traynor is an egregious selection for the hall...he's not at all. Best of all time, even in 1976? That's probably a stretch. He may not make the top ten now, certainly not the top 5 which is something no other player on that 1976 Topps All Time team would say (you can argue Cochrane, but he is one of a cluster of catchers, though Bench or Campy would be my pick). We have had a good run of quality third basemen in the last 40 or so years and are in the midst of quite probably the best crop of third sackers ever top to bottom (Bryant, Arenado, Donaldson, Machado, Beltre, Seager, Turner, Ramirez, Rendon, plus others like Longoria, Lamb, Bregman, Castellanos, Frazier etc.). Interesting times.

It was Sporting News list. Even in 1999, they still had Traynor highly rated. #70 all time (Cochrane was #65) and the 4th best 3rd baseman behind Schmidt, Brett and Mathews with Brooks and Boggs below, but ranked.