REA surprises

[ullmandds]

I realize the auction isn't over yet...but I am surprised at some prices so far.

One that stands out is the e102 Cobb...psa 5 I think. It's really nice...but 20K+ nice?????

PSA 9 Rose Rookie seems a bit lower than in the past artificial run up.

Ridiculous prices for o smith/r henderson rookies...I mean seriously!!!!

[Stonepony]

I agree, I thought I was in the running for that e102 Cobb....until it blew up

[btcarfagno]

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

[MikeGarcia]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

..I've done that after over-bidding to start with and then suddenly remembered that there's a 20% BP....

..

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

haha...twice for me this auction!!!!

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

haha...twice for me this auction!!!!

I guess that your anger and disgust is why you want to sabotage BST threads....Get over it Pete....

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by CMIZ5290

I guess that your anger and disgust is why you want to sabotage BST threads....Get over it Pete....

really Kevin? if u really wanted to sell a card...or multiple in your case...it doesn't take years and years to do...atleast for most people!

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

really Kevin? if u really wanted to sell a card...or multiple in your case...it doesn't take years and years to do...atleast for most people!

You're right, I agree...

[Michael Peich]

"anger and disgust"?

Come on, Kevin, that was not what Pete indicated as I read it. He made a statement of fact, one that I have also felt. But there was no "anger and disgust" feeling when I was glad that someone had outbid me.

This is a public forum where we share our mutual interests. Let's keep it at that.

Cheers,
Mike

[CMIZ5290]

Originally Posted by Michael Peich

"anger and disgust"?

Come on, Kevin, that was not what Pete indicated as I read it. He made a statement of fact, one that I have also felt. But there was no "anger and disgust" feeling when I was glad that someone had outbid me.

This is a public forum where we share our mutual interests. Let's keep it at that.

Cheers,
Mike

You're right...I agree

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Michael Peich

"anger and disgust"?

Come on, Kevin, that was not what Pete indicated as I read it. He made a statement of fact, one that I have also felt. But there was no "anger and disgust" feeling when I was glad that someone had outbid me.

This is a public forum where we share our mutual interests. Let's keep it at that.

Cheers,
Mike

right Mike...I'd say a feeling of mild relief is more like it!

[Sean]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

I've had that happen a few times... and looking back now, I'm also sorry that I didn't get a couple of those items.

[Shoeless Moe]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

Me too, no idea what I was thinking, funny you said that I almost started a thread with that as the topic. Best outbid email I ever got.

[Bliggity]

Originally Posted by btcarfagno

Did you ever place a bid at an auction and later pray that someone would outbid you? That happened to me with this REA auction.

My surprise (and relief) was when someone finally did late this afternoon. Big sigh of relief.

Tom C

Yup. I forgot Gray with stats was the rare T205 variation, and bid too high on the Gray no stats by mistake. If someone wants to outbid me in the last couple hours here, that'd be great

[Stonepony]

The beautiful E98 Matty just left my orbit

[edjs]

The D310 Berry at $1400 surprises me. I know it is highest graded, but so are the others, and some of those are lower pops.

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by Stonepony

The beautiful E98 Matty just left my orbit

i wish my consignment(s) would enter the orbit...let alone leave it!!!!!

[gnaz01]

Originally Posted by ullmandds

i wish my consignment(s) would enter the orbit...let alone leave it!!!!!

Agreed

[btcarfagno]

Both of the women in baseball lots are far above what I would have expected. The 1890-91 Young Ladies Baseball Club cabinet isn't easy to find but not super tough either. I see one or two per year trade hands. Usually in the $300-400 range. This one is at $840 with the sauce. Woof. And the group of 20 N48's at $2,750 with sauce. Most are in really bad shape. I dunno. Maybe they are worth $130-150 each. But buying 20 would think the per card would come down.

Tom C

[edjs]

I just got the first warning e-mail. Why do I feel like a pony that got the whip on his flank, heading into the home stretch?

[btcarfagno]

Originally Posted by edjs

I just got the first warning e-mail. Why do I feel like a pony that got the whip on his flank, heading into the home stretch?

If this auction were a horse race I'd be headed to the glue factory. I got shut out of the lots I was interested in some time ago.

Tom C

[kailes2872]

There are 2 '55 Clemente PSA 6's. One is about 4500, one is 2500. I keep looking but I can't seem to tell what would be driving a $2000 difference.

The PSA 5 and PSA 6 '54 Bowman #66 Williams are going much cheaper that what I paid for it in April.

My theory that card prices only go up when I am actively looking for the card has been validated!

[edjs]

Originally Posted by kailes2872

My theory that card prices only go up when I am actively looking for the card has been validated!

I think that theory applies to many of us!

[spacktrack]

Fair warning. The auction will close without notice prior to 12 am midnight eastern.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by spacktrack

Fair warning. The auction will close without notice prior to 12 am midnight eastern.

How much? I should add, we all thank you for ending your auction at a reasonable time.

[x2drich2000]

I know they are tough especially in "higher" grades, but $8k plus juice for the lot of 3 E105s really shocked me.

DJ

[paul]

The Honey Boys (especially Rousch and Speaker) went for less than I expected. Everything else went for much more than I could stand.

[CW]

Henderson PSA 10 at $21,600 and Jordan RC PSA 10 at $16,800 (both include BP) were somewhat low and surprising compared to past results.

[glynparson]

I agree, those saying the Henderson 10 went high have not been paying attention I guess. It might be higher than we feel it should be, but relative to other sales it was in no way out of line (high).

[Bliggity]

Here's a wild one. VCP average on a PSA 6 1953 Bowman Mantle is about $1,700. A PSA 6 last night went for $4,800. And a BVG 6 went for 6,000. Both were nice-looking cards, but that seems crazy.

[rats60]

Originally Posted by Bliggity

Here's a wild one. VCP average on a PSA 6 1953 Bowman Mantle is about $1,700. A PSA 6 last night went for $4,800. And a BVG 6 went for 6,000. Both were nice-looking cards, but that seems crazy.

Another PSA 6 went for 1320, but it wasn't centered.

[h2oya311]

Originally Posted by glynparson

I agree, those saying the Henderson 10 went high have not been paying attention I guess. It might be higher than we feel it should be, but relative to other sales it was in no way out of line (high).

Agreed. The pop of 10's on the 1980 Henderson is incredibly low (lots of 9's), but to pay $20k+ vs. $300+ for the difference between a 10 and a 9 is pretty insane!

[Prince Hal]

How about the "possibly unique" 1980 Topps/Pepsi Guidry going for $6,000!

[Paul S]

Originally Posted by Prince Hal

How about the "possibly unique" 1980 Topps/Pepsi Guidry going for $6,000!

To a elder Yankee fan that remembers (that's me) who can't afford seats at The Stadium (me again) could be worth it just for someone with a memory (me once more) and long pockets (not me).

[ullmandds]

Originally Posted by h2oya311

Agreed. The pop of 10's on the 1980 Henderson is incredibly low (lots of 9's), but to pay $20k+ vs. $300+ for the difference between a 10 and a 9 is pretty insane!

yes exactly!

[Yoda]

The T3 Lajoie no offer went for a tasty number.

[oldjudge]

I was surprised by what the Radbourn flipping the bird N172 went for. Here is the N173 version:

[Danny Smith]

Originally Posted by x2drich2000

I know they are tough especially in "higher" grades, but $8k plus juice for the lot of 3 E105s really shocked me.

DJ

This one totally blows my mind. Never have I seen prices like this for relatively “common” mellos.

[Jason]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

I was surprised by what the Radbourn flipping the bird N172 went for. Here is the N173 version:

Nice N173 Jay. I was an early underbidder in the Bird Flip card. I had no idea it what it was worth and barely fit into the equation!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Danny Smith

This one totally blows my mind. Never have I seen prices like this for relatively “common” mellos.

$9600 total for 3 common mello mints has to be a world record. I would have thought the final with hammer would have only been the BP of the equation (1600).

[x2drich2000]

Originally Posted by Leon

$9600 total for 3 common mello mints has to be a world record. I would have thought the final with hammer would have only been the BP of the equation (1600).

Personally, I would have gone after them if they stayed down in the $1600 range. I expected them to go somewhere in the $2800-$3200 range since they were extremely nice looking for mello mints.

[T206Collector]

Something about the phrase “mello mint” has always intrigued me - sort of relaxed me. Never even considered acquiring one, but I could see a fascination with the brand that would cause a bidding war on some nice looking examples.

[ullmandds]

mellomints have quite possible the coolest backs in the bizness!!!!

[barrysloate]

The high bids on the Mello Mints are almost certainly the result of just two bidders going back and forth. Therefore, it may not be an accurate indicator of what the cards are really worth.

[Danny Smith]

Originally Posted by barrysloate

The high bids on the Mello Mints are almost certainly the result of just two bidders going back and forth. Therefore, it may not be an accurate indicator of what the cards are really worth.

Amen to that. I have 40 of the set of 50 and not even some of the top Cards in the set would reach those numbers if I were to sell.

[tbob]

Originally Posted by edjs

The D310 Berry at $1400 surprises me. I know it is highest graded, but so are the others, and some of those are lower pops.

That one made me scratch my head too. I was looking to upgrade my Berry but around $2000 including the vig was a bit much. I bought several of the D310s because it is just tough to find 310s in great shape and I thought the prices were decent.

[edjs]

Originally Posted by tbob

That one made me scratch my head too. I was looking to upgrade my Berry but around $2000 including the vig was a bit much. I bought several of the D310s because it is just tough to find 310s in great shape and I thought the prices were decent.

The only two I didn't need were the Berry and the Sutor. I picked up the Chadbourne and the Murray. Besides Berry, Heister went for $960, Mohler went for $1560, LaLonge went for $720, Vitt went for $600, and Lewis went for $600. I know these are most highest graded, Berry is a great classic pose, and Mohler is a popular player, but still, there were a bunch of low end D310s on e-bay that the seller could barely sell (I think he still has four listed). The two I bought were also highest graded, and Chadbourne is one of only two graded (I was shocked to see it, let alone win it). I don't put a lot of stock in the pop reports on these, I am pretty sure most collectors don't have them graded (the ones I have graded I bought that way). I love this set, I'm up to 44 different, but I was starting to think there are only two or three guys collecting this set besides me. Hopefully this signals a resurgence of this set!