1915 Cracker Jack Joe Jackson SGC 2

[Madi$on18joshua]

Where do you think this card end up at?

There is ANOTHER 1915 Cracker Joe Jackson SGC 2 in Mile High's new auction!!! WOW!

https://milehighcardco.com/LotDetail...entoryid=96981


https://bid.robertedwardauctions.com...?itemid=161686


The last PSA 2 sold for $63k at Heritage in May of this year. A SGC 1 that had a couple small holes in it just sold a couple weeks ago for $30k @ Heritage also.

[Jstottlemire1]

I’m thinking 42-44k range realistically. I’m interested in seeing others thoughts also. This auction has many great Jackson items in it.

[ronniehatesjazz]

$42-44k is a good guess but it's so hard to tell with a card like this. Could easily see a bidding war push it north of $50k or even inline with the $63k or above. IMO the third best looking CJ across the 14-15 sets, just behind the Cobb and Matty (probably just my bias for big names over aesthetics)... a serious collector with deep pockets would love to add this one to the collection or perhaps, sadly, see it as an opportunity to flip down the road. Best Shoeless Joe card available.

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by ronniehatesjazz

$42-44k is a good guess but it's so hard to tell with a card like this. Could easily see a bidding war push it north of $50k or even inline with the $63k or above. IMO the third best looking CJ across the 14-15 sets, just behind the Cobb and Matty (probably just my bias for big names over aesthetics)... a serious collector with deep pockets would love to add this one to the collection or perhaps, sadly, see it as an opportunity to flip down the road. Best Shoeless Joe card available.

I agree completely. I wouldn’t be surprised to see near 50k either. I went conservative due to auction ending time with holidays and the fact there is strong presence of Jackson represented in the auction. It will be exciting to watch.

[brianp-beme]

This thread should be moved to the main forum where all proper discussions about ending auction prices on extremely expensive cards belong.


Brian

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

I agree completely. I wouldn’t be surprised to see near 50k either. I went conservative due to auction ending time with holidays and the fact there is strong presence of Jackson represented in the auction. It will be exciting to watch.

100% agree about the time of year being an issue but anything below $50k is a great buy IMO. Ive gotten some really great buys in December. This is one of my favorite cards, it absolutely beautiful.

Do you think the SGC hurts or helps the price, or does it have a neutral effect?

[mrreality68]

it seems like a split auction

many great cards seem low at this point but seems to low like the bidders are waiting till the final day and others like the 1916 Gimbel Ad back Jackson and the 2 Rookie Jacksons that seems to have a stronger price than I would have thought at this point.

I believe it will POP and be over $50K

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

I agree completely. I wouldn’t be surprised to see near 50k either. I went conservative due to auction ending time with holidays and the fact there is strong presence of Jackson represented in the auction. It will be exciting to watch.

100% agree about the time of year being an issue but anything below $50k is a great buy IMO. Ive gotten some really great buys in December. This is one of my favorite cards, it absolutely beautiful.

Do you think the SGC hurts or helps the price, or does it have a neutral effect?

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by Madi$on18joshua

100% agree about the time of year being an issue but anything below $50k is a great buy IMO. Ive gotten some really great buys in December. This is one of my favorite cards, it absolutely beautiful.

Do you think the SGC hurts or helps the price, or does it have a neutral effect?

I don’t think Sgc slab should effect an iconic prewar card at all tbh. I have my bid in on the card personally as well to a certain number to match my PSA copy. I hope it does well, but also wouldn’t be heartbroken to have it land in my home either haha.

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

I don’t think Sgc slab should effect an iconic prewar card at all tbh. I have my bid in on the card personally as well to a certain number to match my PSA copy. I hope it does well, but also wouldn’t be heartbroken to have it land in my home either haha.

I have a bid in as well and would be absolutely thrilled to snag it.

I cannot believe its not on the first page, its literally buried in the auction, lot number 940. I would be extremely frustrated if it were my card, IMO this should be on the first page in the top 25 lots!

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by Madi$on18joshua

I have a bid in as well and would be absolutely thrilled to snag it.

I cannot believe its not on the first page, its literally buried in the auction, lot number 940. I would be extremely frustrated if it were my card, IMO this should be on the first page in the top 25 lots!

I agree a top 10 iconic card. It’s strongly centered also with strong color.

[Fred]

Well, there's another set I won't be starting...

[Rhotchkiss]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

I agree a top 10 iconic card

No doubt it’s a beast, but it is a 1915. I would say the 1914 (3x rarer than the 1915 and a year earlier), is a top ten iconic card.

I really like that the 1915 example has the caramel stains- very nice card/example. Good luck to all.

[Jstottlemire1]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

No doubt it’s a beast, but it is a 1915. I would say the 1914 (3x rarer than the 1915 and a year earlier), is a top ten iconic card.

I really like that the 1915 example has the caramel stains- very nice card/example. Good luck to all.

Yeah 💯 . I often group Jackson and Cobb 14/15 images in referral to top card. I should have said pose. The rarity of 14’ is def taking precedence in each of those CJ issues. 14’ certainly scarce and more value, yet not a crazy amount of 15’s either making them pretty coveted as well. I’d like to have each year in my collection.

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by Rhotchkiss

No doubt it’s a beast, but it is a 1915. I would say the 1914 (3x rarer than the 1915 and a year earlier), is a top ten iconic card.

I really like that the 1915 example has the caramel stains- very nice card/example. Good luck to all.

The caramel stain in the lower right of the card anchors the image which has always had a "falling off to the left" dynamic, that's what gives this card superior eye appeal, that and the really cool caramel stains on the front of his uniform/sleeves.

[BRoberts]

Originally Posted by Madi$on18joshua

I cannot believe its not on the first page, its literally buried in the auction, lot number 940. I would be extremely frustrated if it were my card, IMO this should be on the first page in the top 25 lots!

Yet you found it. Whew!

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

Yeah 💯 . I often group Jackson and Cobb 14/15 images in referral to top card. I should have said pose. The rarity of 14’ is def taking precedence in each of those CJ issues. 14’ certainly scarce and more value, yet not a crazy amount of 15’s either making them pretty coveted as well. I’d like to have each year in my collection.

I agree I would love to have one of each year for my collections. So if everyone would kindly stop bidding maybe I would have a chance

[Jstottlemire1]

With a few days left I wish everyone the best of luck.

[Vintagedeputy]

Originally Posted by mrreality68

So if everyone would kindly stop bidding maybe I would have a chance

That'll never happen. One of my pet peeves about bidders. I can't understand why people keep bidding stuff up all day, every day.

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by Jstottlemire1

With a few days left I wish everyone the best of luck.

Josh there is another Jackson same grade @ Mile High so you've got an even better chance of landing one!

https://milehighcardco.com/LotDetail...entoryid=96981

[Madi$on18joshua]

Originally Posted by ronniehatesjazz

$42-44k is a good guess but it's so hard to tell with a card like this. Could easily see a bidding war push it north of $50k or even inline with the $63k or above. IMO the third best looking CJ across the 14-15 sets, just behind the Cobb and Matty (probably just my bias for big names over aesthetics)... a serious collector with deep pockets would love to add this one to the collection or perhaps, sadly, see it as an opportunity to flip down the road. Best Shoeless Joe card available.

last few hours left and your prediction is holding up. its sitting at $40k w/ the BP. I wonder how many different bidders are a part of this 40 that have bid.