Let's see your postwar "holy grail"!

[Doug]

Since there's a thread going on the prewar side about the 19th century "holy grail" I figured it would be fun to see which single card is the highlight of everyone's postwar collection. It should be interesting to see what everyone comes up with!

[sflayank]

here it is

[Rob D.]

 

[JasonL]

took me more than 15 years to find them both, and I will never move them, since they are my cousins. I'm just glad they both have fairly good registration and color.

[Chris D.]

[Griffins]

Card wise, it was probably this one. Now if I can just find Collins/Martin and Tinker/Martin


In the pack collection, these two were brutally tough

[GoldenAge50s]

I have always had a complete 1954 Bowman set since I bought the packs back in the day & put it together, but was never able to pull a #66 TW (or even knew it existed back then!) About a year or so ago I found the one I wanted to really finish off my set, so this card is quite special to me!

A tiny, very lite stain in the upper right corner is almost unnoticeable considering the great centering, spotless glossy surface & really nice corners!

[Leon]

I don't collect post war per se but do go up to 1949, so that is certainly post war. Here is a 1946 card (not many from that year) that I really enjoy.....

[toppcat]

For me it's been the 1968 Topps 3d's-I only have the one:



Not as attractive but even harder to find, again my only one (of course, I mostly collect Tops types!):

[onlychild]

For years it was the only one of all Bell Brands graded PSA 9. Still a 1 of 2. I think a Koufax 9 sold for over $25K.




Kevin
.
.
.

[Scott T]

I collect Nate Colbert cards and this "card" was even harder to find the the 1972 Venezuelan sticker cards.

[cardinalcollector]

You just can't beat '68 3Ds, and all though the autographed card is from 1992, it is tough to find.

[sox1903wschamp]

I had to add my Hockey Grail despite this being a Baseball thread

[paul]

One of these:

[bijoem]

[GoldenAge50s]

That's a BEAUTIFUL Robinson Joe!

[Exhibitman]

Though not baseball this is my favorite postwar card. It is the only 1951 Ringside of my cousin w/autograph that I've ever seen:



In baseball, I don't have a real "grail" card; this is probably about as close as I can come:

[tedzan]

The combination of extremely tough to find and very sought after makes this 1949 LEAF GUM Co. card of Paige
high on the list for set collectors, or type collectors.







TED Z

[murcerfan]

I could only upload 5 pics for this post, I was just getting warmed up.

[Rickyy]

An odd one...but I like it...1976 Topps unissued proof of Bobby Darwin pictured with his helmet instead of the cap in the regular issue...

[Batter67up]

1955 Sandy Koufax and 1954 Stan Musial RedHeart Dog Food

[qj-baseball]

Collecting: Mays-Banks-Aaron

[4815162342]

Originally Posted by Doug

Since there's a thread going on the prewar side about the 19th century "holy grail" I figured it would be fun to see which single card is the highlight of everyone's postwar collection. Mine's pretty obvious, but it should be interesting to see what everyone comes up with!

Originally Posted by Doug

1952 Topps Mickey Mantle PSA 1.5 FR $5250:

http://shop.ebay.com/bearcat-doug/m...._sop=12&_rdc=1

Woah, that was a quick "Holy Grail" to "For Sale"! Why are you selling it? It's a gorgeous 1.5!

[MBMiller25]

My trifecta of Post War Holy Grail Cards. I would love to add a PSA 7- 1948 Jackie Robinson RC and PSA 7 1954 Hank Aaron RC to this post one day.

[Marckus99]

Probably my 55 Rodeo - Power (Pink) - no wax finish, cut from a sheet.
Sorry no scan.

Mark

[cwazzy]

It's no Mantle but at least it's a '52 Topps. I'm on a limited budget so I never thought I would actually own this card.

[insidethewrapper]

Here's one of the tough post war cards I have. As a Tiger collector I prize this one:

[Exhibitman]

Nice cards! That Houtteman is a great one; legendarily difficult.

[ichieh]

My new acquision

[Robextend]

Here are my post-war favs from my collection:

[hcv123]

Originally Posted by sflayank

here it is

Never get tired of seeing that image.

[hcv123]

So many great choices, how do I pick only 1. Okay, I've narrowed it to items I laready have digital images of and came up with 2

1) Possibly 1 of a kind 1967 pinup sticker

2) 1962 Venezuelan

[CW]

I'm surprised this thread didn't get more action back in '09.

Here's my postwar grail...

[dabigyankeeman]

Its a tie for me between these two Mantles. The 1951 is the true rookie card, but the 1952 is the most popular. If i had to pick just one, yes, it would be the 1952 Topps.

[Doug]

Originally Posted by 4815162342

Woah, that was a quick "Holy Grail" to "For Sale"! Why are you selling it? It's a gorgeous 1.5!

Good thing I sold that one (and the SGC 30, PSA 4 and PSA 3 I had before it) or I wouldn't have this one now!

[slidekellyslide]

My postwar holy grails - 1953-54 Weaver Wafers Lincoln Chiefs

[BCauley]

My favorite card ever made. I finally got one a few months back after selling off a whole bunch of useless game used bat/jersey cards.

[Zach Wheat]

Originally Posted by insidethewrapper

Here's one of the tough post war cards I have. As a Tiger collector I prize this one:

Wow nice Houteeman. How did that grade out at only a "1"? Nice card for a toughie card/set.

Zach

[Kehfee]

It's not my most expensive or nicest post war card but I'd say my 54 Bowman Ted Williams in SGC 50 is the grail. Although I'd really like to own one in an 8 or higher.

[Braves3]

My Holy Grail is a gem mint 1962 Salada of #48 Dick Williams (name on right). To go along with it I also have the Brandt (Orioles) and Bailey (C by ear). All I need now is to find a Killebrew variation.

I also have a 1955 Armour Kuenn (Spaced - correct last line) in gold. Got that in a package of hot dogs when I was a kid

[Doug]

Originally Posted by Braves3

Got that in a package of hot dogs when I was a kid

eBay needs to come up with a new rule that every time you buy a card the seller has to provide you with a piece of gum, pack of hot dogs, or whatever originally came with the card.

[bobsbbcards]

Originally Posted by Braves3

My Holy Grail is a gem mint 1962 Salada of #48 Dick Williams (name on right). To go along with it I also have the Brandt (Orioles) and Bailey (C by ear). All I need now is to find a Killebrew variation.

Very impressive for the three Salada coin variations, but you have me stumped on the last one. What is the Killebrew variation?

[sflayank]

nice bob
hi have an empty space waiting for the dick williams when youre ready
the killebrew name is angled or straight across is a real variation
the bailey c level ear not a fan of
larry

[sflayank]

hi
how much for the gold harvey kuenn
sflayank@aol.com

[ValKehl]

back when I was a kid and Dad took me to old Griffith Stadium. I got these signatures in person at local shows 15 - 20 years ago.
Val

[Zach Wheat]

Originally Posted by sflayank

here it is

SFla...what card is that? Thanks.

Zach Wheat

[frankhardy]

I collect Cardinals team sets and Topps Cardinals autographs. I couldn't decide which test issue or insert to chose, so I chose a very rare modern autographed card.

I only know of 2 that exist, and this is one of them.