March Pick Up Thread

[Rhotchkiss]

Congrats Pete! That is a find.

Great miscut Mike

Steve, great pick up. One of the best poses out there

Congrats to everyone else on some awesome pickups

[MVSNYC]

Thanks Ryan!

Joshua, awesome T206 pick ups!

[Brian Van Horn]

Not being ghoulish, but the memorial stripe was what sold me. Not crazy about the "B" written on the cap or paper loss at neck.

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by pcoz

I believe the only Orange one known at this point. Lucky to have found it.

Wow and congrats

Great pickup

[BobbyStrawberry]

Originally Posted by PrewarCollective

It may not be special to some of you high rollers but I picked this up at the Dallas show last weekend and I’m damn proud to own it!

Love it!

[theshowandme]

Purchased this morning, now to bite my fingernails until it arrives...

[hammertime]

A few recent things for me...

[abmchenry]

Was finally able to land a Dummy Hoy card after years of searching for a semi affordable one (!!!).

[BobC]

Originally Posted by abmchenry

Was finally able to land a Dummy Hoy card after years of searching for a semi affordable one (!!!).

Saw that and was watching it on Ebay. Congrats, nice pickup of a card for a long sought after player.

Was a bit surprised at the final price as well, given the condition of that WG1 playing card. Makes you wonder where it would have ended up if the card was all there. Still a very tough and extremely rare issue you never seem to find for sale/auction.

[abmchenry]

Originally Posted by BobC

Saw that and was watching it on Ebay. Congrats, nice pickup of a card for a long sought after player.

Was a bit surprised at the final price as well, given the condition of that WG1 playing card. Makes you wonder where it would have ended up if the card was all there. Still a very tough and extremely rare issue you never seem to find for sale/auction.

Thanks Bob, I am pretty excited about it. Hard to know what a card this heavily trimmed is "supposed" to cost. I have seen a few Old Judge Hoys for sale here and there but they have all been in great condition and quite expensive. I figured I wasn't likely to get a better shot at owning a Hoy or a WG1 in any condition, so I just went for it. Will now try to learn more here and elsewhere about this strange set....

[Natswin2019]

Some nice additions to my RVA pre war collection. Nice to add these too next to the old mill versions that I already have.

[MVSNYC]

A sincere thank you to one of the greatest T206 collectors, and gentleman, Sonny T.

[Joe_G.]

For those who study Old Judge cards closely, a run of Fa, Fb, and Fc Detroits courtesy the February Heritage auctions (outside of my small pick-up an impressive grouping of OJs not often seen). These Fa & Fb Detroits are 1888 re-issues of 1887 zero numbered cards. While these re-issues are rarely seen they don't seem to command much of a premium as few collect all variations and are happy with the 1887 initial issue. Most Fb Detroits are new poses of new players, but Goodwin also re-issued most if not all the 1887 cards in 1888 as either Fa or Fb.



The Fa cards typically added first and middle initial (L. G. Twitchell in this case) and the Fa type was source of many misspellings (such as Ganzel becoming Gauzel, Weidman becoming G. E. Weichman, etc.).

The Fb card is Ganzel and was a new add to Carto listing for me (hadn't been studied or recorded previously). These re-issues of existing poses haven't been catalogued with same vigor although this would be first example I've seen in decades of close watching.

The Fc card is of Campau which was introduced to N172 set in 1888 with Kansas City and re-issued in 1889 with Detroit. Happy to add this image upgrade of Campau.

[abmchenry]

Originally Posted by Joe_G.

For those who study Old Judge cards closely, a run of Fa, Fb, and Fc Detroits courtesy the February Heritage auctions (outside of my small pick-up an impressive grouping of OJs not often seen). These Fa & Fb Detroits are 1888 re-issues of 1887 zero numbered cards. While these re-issues are rarely seen they don't seem to command much of a premium as few collect all variations and are happy with the 1887 initial issue. Most Fb Detroits are new poses of new players, but Goodwin also re-issued most if not all the 1887 cards in 1888 as either Fa or Fb.



The Fa cards typically added first and middle initial (L. G. Twitchell in this case) and the Fa type was source of many misspellings (such as Ganzel becoming Gauzel, Weidman becoming G. E. Weichman, etc.).

The Fb card is Ganzel and was a new add to Carto listing for me (hadn't been studied or recorded previously). These re-issues of existing poses haven't been catalogued with same vigor although this would be first example I've seen in decades of close watching.

The Fc card is of Campau which was introduced to N172 set in 1888 with Kansas City and re-issued in 1889 with Detroit. Happy to add this image upgrade of Campau.

Joe I am a novice when it comes to Old Judge, I only have one of a relatively obscure Giant. What do Fa, Fb, and Fc mean in that context?

[bandrus1]

Raw binder pick ups headed to sgc

[mrreality68]

Originally Posted by bandrus1

Raw binder pick ups headed to sgc

Congrats on the Raw pickups

[Joe_G.]

Originally Posted by abmchenry

Joe I am a novice when it comes to Old Judge, I only have one of a relatively obscure Giant. What do Fa, Fb, and Fc mean in that context?

When the British Cartophilic Society cataloged the Old Judge set by grouping certain card types by different letter designations. All 1888 N172s are found as one of two types, Fa and Fb, and it has to do with the size of the advertising found on the bottom of the card. All 1889 OJs introduce the word "FACTORY" in the advertising. Fc style would hang on for 1890 as well but with addition of a "NL" or "PL" to designate National League or Players league.

This is a high level explanation of 1888-1890, a bit more complicated for 1886-1887. The Old Judge book is a great resource to understand how the set evolved year to year.

[jiw98]

I found these at a show this weekend.

[RCMcKenzie]

Nice cards, Joe. I think I was bidding on the Campau. Hopefully a KC version will turn up soon.

I traded away a John Ewing for another n172 and was able to replace it in the run of Heritage auctions with this lesser, but still nice example.

[atx840]

Great MCs Mike, agreed he is one of the best out there

[GasHouseGang]

Been slowly working on the T205 HOFers.

[abmchenry]

Thanks Joe for the explanation. These are a bit out of my league price wise generally but I'm now wanting to learn more about this set, so I think I will try and track down that book. Thanks again.

[kkkkandp]

Originally Posted by Joe_G.

Happy to add this image upgrade of Campau.

Nice Campau pickup, Joe! 👍

[pawpawdiv9]

added this for my brother to enjoy- been looking for a nice example

[whaler]

eBay pickup

[abmchenry]

I love Obaks and I love those Obaks!

[Epps]

Excited to pick up an oversized, miscut T210

4143A62F-B8CC-48EA-8F72-623941BD3E34.jpg

[Spike]

Tough hit to my R314 Goudey Premiums arrived this week

[kkkkandp]

Glad to have finally added an N172 of Charlie Ganzel (thanks, Jay! ).

Ganzel remained in the Boston area after his retirement from the Beaneaters in 1897. He remained very close to the game in various ways: playing for several local semipro teams, umpiring, and coaching the baseball team of my alma mater, Williams College. He guided the team to a couple of championships around the turn of the 20th Century. Somewhat oddly, he appears in two of the college team yearbook photos in two versions of his old Boston uniform.

[bnorth]

Picked up this Coyle as an upgrade today.

[asphaltman]

[paleocards]

My 2nd OJ. Very happy with the contrast in this image of "Big Sam."

thompson87f_PSA3.jpg

[ValKehl]

Gorgeous card of "Big Sam." To me, this is an EXMT card when it comes to OJ cards!

[Leon]

Originally Posted by ValKehl

Gorgeous card of "Big Sam." To me, this is an EXMT card when it comes to OJ cards!

+1. But aesthetics don't matter too much in grading...
.

[CobbSpikedMe]

I just picked up another w516-1 Becker Prize Back card and I'm very excited about it. It's another dupe for me, but I pick these up whenever I see them at a fair price. I love these things.




.

[hammertime]

[Casey2296]

Originally Posted by CobbSpikedMe

I just picked up another w516-1 Becker Prize Back card and I'm very excited about it. It's another dupe for me, but I pick these up whenever I see them at a fair price. I love these things.
.

Nice pick up Andy.

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by Casey2296

Nice pick up Andy.

Thanks Phil. I love these things. Always exciting to see one let alone pick one up.



.

[edhans]

Nice, Andy! Are you coming to the National this year? I'll bring mine if you are and we'll see if we can fit any together.

[fkm_bky]

Beautiful Terry! It's a shame what PSA did with that slab though.

Bill

Originally Posted by hammertime

[hammertime]

Originally Posted by fkm_bky

Beautiful Terry! It's a shame what PSA did with that slab though.

Bill

Thanks! Yeah not my favorite either but it has the mylar sleeve so at least it doesn't rattle around.

[VintageBen]

Another Cobby


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[NYYFan63]

Picked this up last week…




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Vintagecatcher]

Excited to add this new "type" to my collection today.

Not only is it my first E270-2 Tin Top, but it also completes my run of George Gibson in the Colgan Chips as I had already had his E254 Star of the Diamond and E270-1 Red Border Colgan's Chips.

It was part of the Skydash Collection.

Thanks to Scott Brockelman and Brockelman Auctions!


Patrick

[CobbSpikedMe]

Originally Posted by edhans

Nice, Andy! Are you coming to the National this year? I'll bring mine if you are and we'll see if we can fit any together.

Ed, my man. Yeah, I was pretty excited to see it on eBay and that my snipe was high enough.

I can't make the National in Chicago this year unfortunately. It's just too far away from me. I would need to bring my family with me as a vacation for them while I'm at the show and four plane tickets is just too much for me right now. Plus a rental car and hotel for a few days. I'd have nothing for the show after all that.

I'd like to meet up sometime though and put them all together and see if we can make a partial strip by matching them all up. That would be awesome!

I'm still looking for a Peckinpaugh for my set, but still have yet to even see one.

Good to hear from you man.



.

[GregMitch34]

Always good to see reports on actual PSA grading times so I will add here that it took three full months to get this M101-2 done, oversized and basic service. Not shipped yet but three months to report on grading. Still, a happy ending, as this is one of the great images ever, I believe, and PSA is incredibly tough in grading these--of 170 graded a handful of "3s" are still the highest. This Griffith got an unexpected 2.5, easily highest graded, so I am very pleased....

https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1680115016

Plus this almost equally unusual and arresting Ed Walsh pulled a PSA 2, again highest graded.

https://www.net54baseball.com/attach...1&d=1680115645

[Joe_G.]

Originally Posted by kkkkandp

Glad to have finally added an N172 of Charlie Ganzel (thanks, Jay! ).

Ganzel remained in the Boston area after his retirement from the Beaneaters in 1897. He remained very close to the game in various ways: playing for several local semipro teams, umpiring, and coaching the baseball team of my alma mater, Williams College. He guided the team to a couple of championships around the turn of the 20th Century. Somewhat oddly, he appears in two of the college team yearbook photos in two versions of his old Boston uniform.

Off the charts sweet Ganzel, that was the last pose I needed when collecting the 1887 Detroits. Great story . . . The Ganzel family is somewhat legendary in early Michigan baseball history with five brothers all playing some form of professional baseball. Charlie and John Ganzel being most prominent. Charlie's son Babe Ganzel would have some success as well.

Love it, congrats Kevin !

[Joe_G.]

Originally Posted by paleocards

My 2nd OJ. Very happy with the contrast in this image of "Big Sam."

Attachment 564039

Stunning, well done !

[MVSNYC]

Happy to get this Cobb back...

[charlietheexterminator]

That’s a beauty Mike. Congrats on another nice Month.