PSA Inconsistency and others

[Archive]

Posted By: FreddyMercury

I have had it!!
I would prefer to remain anonymous in this post for good reason. I have been grading cards forever and its getting ridiculous. I am full time dealer and can no longer play the grading companies game. I used to send in a card, get an honest grade and be done with it. No More. This started out to get a card graded and quickly escalated into a test of the grading companies, particularly PSA.
1. sent in a Goudey Gehrig along with several other Goudeys from the same collection. All cards graded except for the Gehrig. They say it was trimmed.
2. Gehrig resent to PSA and receives a 2.
3. Gehrig resent to PSA and receives a 5.
4. Gehrig resent to PSA and was not holdered due to restoration.
5. Gehrig resent to PSA and receives a 3.
6. Gehrig resent to PSA. They say it was trimmed.
7. Gehrig sent to SGC and receives a 4.
8. Gehrig sent to SGC and receives a 2.
9. Gehrig resent to PSA and receives a 5.
10. Gehrig resent to PSA and receives a 3.
11. Gehrig resent to PSA. They say it was trimmed..

Has anyone else had inconsistency problems like this? I know it was a waste of money in grading fees but it shows how 1 card can be viewed so many different ways. When will they make a computer/scanner that can grade cards consistently and honestly?