Top Ten Part 2- Cdvs, Cabinets, Trade Cards, etc.

[GaryPassamonte]

Piggybacking on the previous Top Ten thread, what do you think are the most valuable cdvs, cabinets, trade cards, hard images(dags, ambros, tintypes)? This might be more subjective than the other Top Ten thread since there is better chance of a piece being unique, although there are unique cards mentioned on the previous thread.

[oldjudge]

Here are a few possibilities. Corey can better address the early photographs.

1869 Cincinnati Peck and Snyder TRADE CARD (not the CdV)
1860 Atlantic’s CdV
1890 Ryder cabinet of Young
1888 N173 Ewing portrait
1890 Walden Smith Delahanty Players League cabinet
1866 Unions CdV with George Wright
1863 Harry Wright or George and Harry Wright Grand Match ticket
1871 Wright or Spalding Mort Rodgers scorecard

[robertsmithnocure]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Here are a few possibilities. Corey can better address the early photographs.

1869 Cincinnati Peck and Snyder TRADE CARD (not the CdV)
1860 Atlantic’s CdV
1890 Ryder cabinet of Young
1888 N173 Ewing portrait
1890 Walden Smith Delahanty Players League cabinet
1866 Unions CdV with George Wright
1863 Harry Wright or George and Harry Wright Grand Match ticket
1871 Wright or Spalding Mort Rodgers scorecard

Awesome list. Subscribed.

[GaryPassamonte]

Maybe 1864 Brooklyn Resolutes and 1865 Brooklyn Atlantics cdvs.

[benjulmag]

Originally Posted by GaryPassamonte

Maybe 1864 Brooklyn Resolutes and 1865 Brooklyn Atlantics cdvs.

As far as CdVs are concerned, the c. 1860 Atlantics to me is the most important/valuable one known. I would put the c. 1864 Resolutes second, and the 1865 Atlantics third (assuming a real one turns up (other than the one at the Library of Congress)). After those two I would put the 1871 Forest Citys with Anson.

[andybecker]

does Cy Young Cleveland Spiders make the list?

[ejharrington]

Originally Posted by oldjudge

Here are a few possibilities. Corey can better address the early photographs.

1869 Cincinnati Peck and Snyder TRADE CARD (not the CdV)
1860 Atlantic’s CdV
1890 Ryder cabinet of Young
1888 N173 Ewing portrait
1890 Walden Smith Delahanty Players League cabinet
1866 Unions CdV with George Wright
1863 Harry Wright or George and Harry Wright Grand Match ticket
1871 Wright or Spalding Mort Rodgers scorecard

Both of the Mort Rogers scorecards listed above should be on the list.

[Directly]

Originally Posted by GaryPassamonte

Piggybacking on the previous Top Ten thread, what do you think are the most valuable cdvs, cabinets, trade cards, hard images(dags, ambros, tintypes)? This might be more subjective than the other Top Ten thread since there is better chance of a piece being unique, although there are unique cards mentioned on the previous thread.

So when determined what are opinions of values $5,000 < $10.000 < $50,000 < ?

[GaryPassamonte]

Tom- I guess that depends on which image you are talking about and some values are not easy to determine, especially if there are no recent sales.