Thinking of selling my dupes

[Bigb13]

Hi guys I am thinking of selling my dupe 1914 Cracker Jacks. Just wondering the best way to go about it. Robert

[Bigb13]

Here's a list of what I have. Bottom list are raw cards that I am taking to the card show in NY this weekend to have graded.
1. Otto Knabe PSA 1.5
4***Larry Doyle PSA 1
8***Rude Oldring SGC A
8***Rude Oldring SGC A
8***Rude Oldring PSA 1
9***Artie Hoffman PSA 1
11**George Stovall SGC 10
15**Reb Russell PSA 2
17**Roger Bresnahan PSA 1 nnob
21**Heinie Zimmerman BVG 1.5
23**Charles Comiskey SGC 10
24**George Mullen PSA 1
24**George Mullen**PSA 2
25**Michael Simon SGC 10
26**James Scott PSA 2.5
27**Bill Carrigan PSA 1
27**Bill Carrigan PSA 1
31**Heine Wagner PSA 1
33**Amos Strunk SGC 30
35**Harry Hooper PSA 1
41**Tommy Leach PSA A
46**Bob Groom PSA 2
51**Nap Rucker PSA A
51**Nap Rucker PSA 1
51**Nap Rucker PSA 1
51**Nap Rucker PSA 3
54**Marty O’Toole PSA 1
58**Wally Schang PSA 1
58**Wally Schang PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler PSA 2
59**Harry Gessler GAI 1.5
63**Babe Adams BVG A
69**John Mc Graw PSA 1
72**Joe Boehling PSA 1
83**Russ Ford PSA 2
97**Rube Benton PSA A
100 Thomas Seton SGC 10
109 Fred Blanding PSA 1
121 Hub Perdue PSA 1
126 Walter Blair PSA 1
129 Ray Caldwell SGC 10
144 Jimmy Walsh PSA 1.5



1****Otto Knabe
5****Ward Miller
8****Rude Oldring
9****Artie Hoffman
11**George Stoval
11**George Stoval
16**Howard Camnitz
17**Roger Bresnahan
17**Roger Bresnahan
26**James Scott
27**William Carrigan
29**Vean Gregg
42**Albert Bridwell
42**Albert Bridwell
48**Harry Lord
49**John Miller
49**John Miller
50**John Hummel
53**Otto Miller
56**Clyde Milan
56**Clyde Milan
58**Walter Schang
59**Harry Gessler
64**James Archer
64**James Archer
64**James Archer
67**Doc Crandall
72**Joseph Boehling
75**Miller Huggins
84**Elmer Kretzer
84**Elmer Kretzer
96**Beals Becker
99**Frank Chance
99**Frank Chance
112 Edward Sweeney
117 Theodore Easterly
121 Hub Perdue
130 Ivy Wingo
132 Leslie Nunamaker
138 Henry Gowdy
140 Daniel Murphy
143 John Daubert

[Leon]

Posting this on the front page was not the way to sell them. I suggest putting prices next to them right where they are now (here). Good luck.

[Bigb13]

Thanks Leon but wasn't trying to sell them on here I just wanted opinions on if I should go with eBay like Pwcc or a big auction house like Heritage. I don't have scans of the cards otherwise I would have put them here. It is about 1/2 the set but don't know if it's better to sell them that way or one at a time. Just looking for opinions. Robert

[CJDave]

PM sent

[Sean]

I've sold cards through PWCC and have gotten good results.

[Leon]

Originally Posted by Bigb13

Thanks Leon but wasn't trying to sell them on here I just wanted opinions on if I should go with eBay like Pwcc or a big auction house like Heritage. I don't have scans of the cards otherwise I would have put them here. It is about 1/2 the set but don't know if it's better to sell them that way or one at a time. Just looking for opinions. Robert

Instead of listing each individually on the front page you could have asked the question something like "Hey guys, I have a bunch of lower grade 1914 CJs, what would be the best way to sell them?"

I think you would probably get a little more selling individually as opposed to a group. You know the normal venues already. Like I said, you might put prices on them right here and see if they sell, saving you some fees.

[Edwolf1963]

Originally Posted by Leon

Like I said, you might put prices on them right here and see if they sell, saving you some fees.

Agreed - I know many won't ask and ignore/move on if they don't see a price. Like seeing "market price" on a restaurant menu - how many times have you inquired about that in the past?

Robert - you may want to try the pricing/sales route here first then move whatever you don't sell to an AH like PWCC, Goodwin, LOTG, etc. I sold the 95-100 or so 1914 CJ's I had here a couple years ago w/great success. I had envisioned moving whatever didn't sell to an AH, but I was cleaned out here in no time (perhaps I priced too low ). I will say there seems to be more CJ's for sale (that I have noticed) of late, so not sure where the supply/demand model is at current? When I sold there didn't seem to be a lot for sale at that time .. or so I perceived.

Good luck w/whatever path you choose.

[Bigb13]

Went with Heritage