[Archive]

Posted By: Max Weder

Julie

If you join the 1919BlackSox group and watch the emails, you will see considerable discussion of 8 Men out. The experts bemoan the fact that Asinof's book has no footnotes or citations, and sources for much of the offered evidence in the book can't easily be identified to be verified.

Thus while the book is presented as fact, much debate still rages about how correct and complete the book actually is. I don't follow the scandal in that level of detail to be able to add anything, but the debate certainly is interesting to watch.

Max