[perezfan]

I wouldn't think twice about the Ruth. It is obviously Clubhouse, and of the time period. It is not a more modern forgery. As long as you know this information going in (along with the fact that it was once mounted to a Blotter) you should be able to determine what it's worth to you.

The value is rather subjective, given the condition issues. The clubhouse Ruth and former mounting scars would drive away some "purist" collectors, while others wouldn't be put off at all.

In typical REA fashion, their estimate is quite conservative, and you can surely expect to pay more than the $1K. A strong McGraw on the sweetspot and Miller Huggins on his own panel are not features that surface very often. Regardless, Rob has provided a very accurate and detailed disclosure, along with the probable reason for the "clubhouse" Ruth. There is really nothing else to question or split hairs over, IMHO.

Hope this helps, and best of luck!