View Single Post
  #46  
Old 02-09-2006, 07:14 AM
Archive Archive is offline
Administrator
 
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 58,359
Default PSA vs. SGC - consistent and accurate?

Posted By: steve f

A few months ago I decided on a second opinion. Realizing that crossover can result in an biased opinion, four SGC, BVG or PSA holdered cards were bustid then submitted to a different company and upgraded; I was looking for the flips but can't locate right now. Though I'm not sure I wish to reveal the players names as it may affect later sales -not mine, but our heirs'.

A. T206 Detroit: *2 -PSA5(mc)^

B. '34 DS A's: *1.5 -BVG3 ^

C. '53 PK Detroit: *3 -PSA4 ^

D. '54 B Yankees: *2 -PSA2 = no change

*will provide the original grading company later on. (I know, B. is a no-brainer.)

Not recommending this method as I believe luck was on our side when selecting the ones that deserve greater scrutiny as neither were returned graded lower or altered/trimmed!

Reply With Quote