Posted By:
E, DanielDax, to answer your question as best I can, I think a really eye popping example of a card that is trimmed and would thus grade authentic, is worth approx. the value of the same card in a PSA2/SGC30. Usually a card that grades a 1 or poor is pretty deficient for eye appeal and thus I feel sells at the bottom of the totem. A 3 already becomes a collector grade, and often cards like caramels will only come in higher grades infrequently, so vg cards sell pretty well. A 2 lies somewhere in between - and I think approximates the value of the card you describe.
Daniel