Quote:
Originally Posted by Peter_Spaeth
My top 10 non-pitchers non-Bonds non-A Rod would probably be
Ruth
Mays
Cobb
Williams
Gehrig
Aaron
Wagner
Musial
Speaker
DiMaggio
Mantle would be right behind these, and Hornsby.
|
I would put Mantle ahead of Joe D but behind Hornsby and the rest.i also have to put Bonds ahead of him. Not A-Rod.
So to me, not including Negro League players like Gibson or Charleston...which is unfortunate....I would put Mantle as the 11th greatest position player of all time. Also behind at least six or seven pitchers.