Here's one in Livingston NJ. The owner, Bob Beck, is a member of this forum:
Bob Beck Sports Collectibles
48 East Northfield Road
Livingston New Jersey 07039
Phone: 973-992-8663
E-Mail:
bob@bobbecksports.com
http://www.bobbecksports.com/
He is quiet but friendly. He has a nice selection of vintage cards (including mostly 1950s-1970s, but does have some pre-war as well) + the new & shiny stuff (singles & wax), as well as autograph memorabilia and supplies, games, and other stuff.
Glenn