Darren: same thing happened to me. I have had this Mays card since 1975 and the Bird/Magic rookie went from the pack into a sleeve. I sent them in and the Mays came back altered and the Bird/Magic came back as a miscut. I waited a couple of months and dropped the off at the National. Here’s what came back.
35108A0A-5361-4034-A5AB-212C3A593313.jpg
AAD7951F-8791-4DF0-A4B4-4C9291079C9C.jpg