[Archive]

Posted By: Jason

Cy Young is a pretty damn good pitcher in my books, but I also think he is one of the most overated.

He is arguably the most famous pitcher of the early era what with the award named after him and the wins record.

However as many here agree he wasn't even the best pitcher in his era. (I think Mathewson, Johnson, and perhaps Waddell were ahead of him)

To me that's overated.