Found a boxscore in the NY Daily News from October 6, 1938. It can be accessed at newspapers.com. That's a pay service, but a SABR member can access it thru the SABR site.
In case you can't/don't find it:
Newark lineup: Schulte 2b; Gleeson lf;Keller rf; Rosar c;Scarascella 1b; May 3b;Chartak cf;Witek ss; Donaldp;Page p;Strincevich p;Stine p Blair and Kelleher ph
KC lineup
avis 1b;Joost 2b;Judnich cf;Matheson rf;Gallagher lf;Miller ss; Riddle c; Wicker p; Makosky p;Washburn p.
The box lists Makosky as the winner and Stine as the loser.