Hi,
I picked up an early Giants ticket (1910s or so, but I am not 100% sure of the date) for about $200 a few years back. Not sure if this is an indication of the value of your ticket, but I wanted to supply you with a data point. I am not a Giants collector, I just like the way the ticket looked - important for my next point.....
As for the early Yankees ticket on eBay, I pushed that price up real hard - I left a huge snipe, someone just happened to want it more. When two people want something badly enough, you can normally throw "normal" pricing info out the window. So be careful using the Highlanders ticket data point as a price reference for your ticket - as far as I can tell, myself and the ultimate winner of the ticket were the only folks "in it" at the end, and I would not be in the mix for your ticket - which isn't to say that some other folks wouldn't be.
|