[Archive]

Posted By: Misunderestimated

I know we have done this one before... Anyway, in order of "undeservingness" I would go with:

1. Rube Marquard
2. Jack Chesbro
3-4. Bobby Wallace/Joe Tinker
5 Chief Bender
Borderline cases: Roger Bresnahan/Elmer Flick/Vic Willis/Johnny Evers/Jake Beckley

(I may be forgetting someone -- someone forgettable given the question)