1 and 2 you are definitely covered no matter what the seller says. They sold you things that Ebay-approved experts say are not as described.
The trimmed card depends. If it was a listing for just a card with no statements on guaranteeing a grade, only that it is real, then to me that one is probably on you. If the description, or a message exchange, had the seller saying that it was unaltered, then that would definitely qualify for a return as well.
|