Thanks Clayton
Just went back to look at the pictures under the black light with the authentic ones and it seems like those two are dirtier, either that or the dark background on them makes them look a little different.
This is the first black light picture with the two authentic ones, cropped in to the part of "...Crack Fielder" that looked the cleanest and then to the "Look Out Mr Pitcher."
And cropped in to the Tunney black light comparison:
