Posted By:
peter chaoChris,
The proper way to look at the HOF is to look at it as an honor. Once the honor has been bestowed it looks awful cheesy to take the trophy away. But at the same time even if a player is clearly better than someone that is currently in the Hall the player should not be automatically picked for the Hall of Fame. The reason for this is admission to the Hall is not something which is earned, it is an honor which the Hall bestows on some and not others who may be equally deserving.
Peter