I saw a thread on the post-war board which said: Show me your under-graded cards.
Here is the link to that thread which is currently running:
http://www.net54baseball.com/showthread.php?t=250623
In addition, how often do we as a group note: "That card has great eye appeal for a 1" or "Looks like a higher grade to me".
I can not make any assumptions about the creator of this site but to me, it sounds hypocritical to complain about something like this if we ourselves constantly brag about such cards. He is looking for an underserved part of the market and I understand the point. Now, we may not agree on the specific cards but if we're going to disagree -- it needs to be on the concept first.
Rich