[Archive]

Posted By: Matt R

Stan, here are two posts on this same thread that say that PSA just doesn't like to grade GAI cards I'll copy them below:


From Jim B.

That is a gorgeous card! I do not think it is trimmed. Unless there is some damage on the back or something imperceptible in the scan (like minor wrinkles), my guess is that its major flaw is that it is in a GAI holder. PSA does not like to grade GAI cards. It does not make sense to me, but... I think if you cracked it out of that holder you would have a legitimate shot at a PSA5, assuming there are no problems that can't be seen in the scan/
JimB

From Jim Lichtman:

"PSA does not like to grade GAI cards."

This has been my experience as well. Crack it out and send it in and you'll have a much better shot.


Are you going to start attacking them for their wild conspiracy theory?