Posted By:
petecldJay,
(just based on my experience, nothing personal)
Cody got a 60 - considering the soft corner (upper, left) and what looks like some very light staining I'm not surprised SGC gave it a 60.
Teddy 50 - Tough call from the scan. Is that a little bit of surface chipping along the left edge and in the bottom, left corner? If there is any chipping, SGC consistantly give those card no better then a 50.
Oliva 80 - seems like a good grade to me. A vintage card with a minor nik won't get an 80 grade. A modern card - yes.
<<...based on those grades, I double dog dare Pete to crack the SGC70 e93 Collins he bought from me and resubmit it for grading.>>
Gosh Beaver, I hate to back down after being "double dog dared" and all but I will agree with you in that I don't think that card would receive the same grade today. Standards are getting tighter.
Leon, what am I thinking right now? Hint: patio.