Posted By:
Dan KoochinBaseball Mogul 2007 for PC will let you play historical teams back to 1900. You can play
for example the 1919 BlackSox Series, or the World Champion Pirates with Honus Wagner.
Its more stat heavy/managerially good, not so good graphically.
For XBox, AllStar Baseball 2004 has several All Time AllStar teams including Ty Cobb and
Babe Ruth. Its also the only game I know of with a Negro League roster including Josh Gibson
and Satchel Paige.