[Kawika]

Cut up the bat for relic cards. Everyone's a winner!
Nah, nah, jus' kiddin'.
It's a tough quandary alright, moral or otherwise. You've gotten good advice across the spectrum already. What I would do falls somewhere in there. We're not taking a vote here so I won't weigh in with my two cents. Sleep on it a day or two and the right answer will manifest itself.
(Was just about to press "Submit Reply" and saw Barry's post. He made a good point. Nobility can turn around and kick you in the derriere. Have you considered relic cards?)