Mike,
I don't have the pencil set to compare with, but they both look legit to me. I guess the non-red could have faded and print issues just led to the offsets, but who knows... The joys of oddball collecting!
That post was graded pre-Jumbo is my guess why PSA gave it a number grade.
And Greg, good to know my dupe Phillies Cigar is in a good home
Nice pickup John!