I guess I will get it started:
1. Staten Island SportsCards
http://www.sisportscards.com/
2. 27 Seguine Avenue
Staten Island, NY 10309-3700
3. (718) 967-7171
4. Hours: Monday-Friday 11-7
Saturday 11-6
Sunday 11-3
5. I will try to find out more info than I already have but so far it is the only store with a hint of vintage I have found in Staten Island. I came in there looking for graded card protectors and started conversating with the owner, who is a really nice guy. We started talking about vintage cards and he pulled out a pile of 1933 and 1934 Goudeys he just acquired. I also believe he is a noted EBAY seller, but as I said I will get more info and share with the board.