My dad and I have literally done this both ways. We started with a raw set many many years ago. Got it fully graded (average condition around 4.5) by PSA, found that it was way too bulky to enjoy the "hobby" aspect of it. Sold off nearly the entire collection and started from scratch about 5 years ago. Last week we got the final card - (Lundgren Chicago) for the basic collection (we're not even considering cards like Wagner for the raw set) and now have it completely in binder form again (average grade provably around vg/ex - ex). Some cards would likely get reasonably high grade - although almost certainly nothing above a "7", but it's just so much more enjoyable to have them all in a binder.
I would add one note, if I was concerned about resale value I would absolutely collect and keep all cards in vg/ex or better in slabs.
Best
Scott
|