Posted By:
AnonymousI'd be mad too, Matt.
Sincere question... If that card had been laying on a scanner bed all by itself, ungraded, would you have been satisfied with its condition? (Not asking if you'd have bought it.) If the answer is yes, then it is a situation of too much dependence on the slabbing of a card.
If it had been raw, and if you'd have bought it, you would not be as upset. You'd have seen how it's short.
Have you asked him to take the card back with you paying postage both ways?