Posted By:
DavidFor the benifit of the someone unfamiliar with the issue, it would have been best to detail what cancelling means. Other than that, I don't have a problem with the grading.
As far as Red Man goes, I have always given a straight grade for what is in front of me, and say whether there is or is not a tab. '1953 Red Man Willie Mays With No Tab Near Mint' is a perfectly acceptable grade to me. It's my job to give an accurate description, not to spood feed.