I don't think I'd refund either unless it's just chump change. The transaction should be in your paypal history, however, so you would be able to look up how much the buyer paid for it.
On a side note, I once purchased an oversized card from a Henry Yee auction. One to two years after the auction ended, I sent the card to Beckett for protection purposes. To my surprise, it came back counterfeit. I contacted Henry about this, and he refunded me most of the purchase, even though I only requested a partial refund. This item was several hundred dollars, so some sellers on ebay still go way beyond the normal expectation. If the situation occurred where I were the seller, I don't know if I would have been as generous.
|