Posted By:
fkw 1910 Orange Borders are listed in most all catalogs, There are 29 known cards listed in the 2006 SCD Catalog (page 274). Mathewson (with complete borders) books for $1,600 NRMT, $640 EX, $320 VG.
You wont see Orange Borders that often, they are scarce. maybe 5-10 a year at most on eBay. The ones you see the most of are the Pirate and Tiger Team Photo cards, they are the most plentiful because they were found on one side of every box. I have only seen maybe 3 Mathewsons total. I have seen the one you got a few times over the years. I always remembered it because of the tack holes, it was originally on eBay misidentified about 5-6 years ago. I and many others on this board are always after these cards (and the similar "Base-Ball Bats" cards). They are in high demand, especially with the complete orange borders.
PS Pop report will be misleading...... since they are handcut PSA didnt grade them for a long time.