[rdixon1208]

Regarding Edgar Martinez, that's a nice Batting Average, but 2247 hits 309 HR's and 1261 RBI's isn't that impressive. Especially for his era. When I think or Edgar Martinez, I think good hitter....not HOFer. Below is a list of his most similar batters according to Baseball-Reference. There's not a HOFer on the list in my opinion....even though some of those guys could play the field too.

Will Clark
Todd Helton
John Olerud
Moises Alou
Magglio Ordonez
Bob Johnson
Bernie Williams
Paul O'Neill
Ellis Burks
Carlos Lee