Posted By:
RichardThe Jennings has paper loss on the front so I think the grade is accurate on that one. All of them seem to have water staining on the back. Perhaps from soaking? The back of the McGann really shows the staining well.
The Chase seems to be low as a 1, but I do think that they are all accurately graded. If any of them, aside from Jennings, was in a 3 holder, I don't think anyone would question it. High end 2, low end 3, not much difference.