[Archive]

Posted By: ramram

Sources for the early 1860's show none of the Newark players matching the names on the 1856 program. Plus, why are the names listed under a "committee". Eighteen names are listed as well when most teams were comprised of nine or ten at that time. Of course, the teams were mostly a fraternal organization and could have a larger number of members but I wouldn't think they would be listed under their "ball club". The only credence I would give this item is that the seller has a strong reputation but without further proof I think it is a long stretch.