Posted By:
warshawlawthe 50 was generous due to centering. I'd have said 40 on it.
As far as grading goes lately, I think SGC's standards are about the same. They beat the heck out of me on a decent N29 with a couple of creases in it (I saw it as a good card, they said fair). My first batch of cross-overs (1948 Leaf boxing, PSA to SGC) were appropriately graded. Most of the PSA 7's I had were really nice 7's, and they drew 86's from SGC. They only rejected two cards as over graded (I told them not to bust 'em out if the SGC grades were lower than the PSA grades), both by one grade. I will probably resubmit them raw and see what they receive. The real test will be the N43 I just got. It is really solid ex to ex+ at least; let's see what they think.