Posted By:
gregor197"Lefty" O'Doul is, however, in the Japanese Baseball Hall of Fame Does this disqualify him? 
Tony Mullane, because of his supposed good looks, had one of my favorite nicknames of all time: "The Apollo of the Box."
However, as a teammate of Fleet Walker's in 1884, he refused to listen to Walker's signals and pitched whatever he wanted without Walker knowing what was coming.