[Archive]

Posted By: Jay Miller

Julie-Certainly the Kelly pose is classic, much like the Whitney with dog Old Judge pose. I'll take your word on Kelly's looks and I certainly agree that he was popular with both his peers and the fans. However, the question remains as to how great a player he really was. Was he better than Ewing? Knowledgeable people who saw both play rank Ewing above Kelly. Where does Kelly rank amongst 19th century stars? That might be a good discussion question.