Quote:
Originally Posted by G1911
.... I don't know how to make this any simpler. None of these words are complex. PED's is not the line; we know this because Pettitte was another PED user caught up in scandal over it they retired. That is why Pettitte is relevant; he is the undeniable proof that claim is false. This is incredibly simple.
I have given no opinion whatsoever on Pettitte, despite this lie of a claim. I liked him as a teen, he was a fun pitcher. It's just completely irrelevant.
I did not say talking about Andy Pettitte as an all time yankee is a canard, I say putting him and not A-Rod is a canard. A-Rod is far and away the all-time Yankee 3B. Pettitte is probably one of the starting pitchers. Your argument that Pettitte is a good retirement choice because he is on the all-time Yankee team is ridiculous, because so is A-Rod. Never did I "pretend" Pettitte is not, it's just that so is A-Rod so this is an absurdist argument.
You do a lot better if you argue against what was actually said and not bullshit you completely made up and is nowhere in the transcript.
|
Here is what your post said "I didn’t choose the canard of an argument that Pettitte is an all-time team Yankee and A-Rod isn’t."
Here is what your recent post said: "I did not say talking about Andy Pettitte as an all time yankee is a canard,"