[Archive]

Posted By: barrysloate

Kevin- You are treating this situation professionally and I agree with two of your points: 1) a dealer can not refuse every card he feels may be slightly overgraded; 2) you clearly posted large pictures for potential bidders to make their own decision. The only exception with this card is it is not a matter of your VG-EX is my VG; in this case, the card is so overgraded that we surmised it was simply mislabelled. The fact that your consignor got hammered on other cards shouldn't have an effect on you pulling this one particular card and telling him it needs to be resubmitted. His hammered cards will be pictured and bidders can submit very high bids if they agree with the harsh grades. I don't think you will lose your consignment over this one unusual situation, unless you already know something about the consignor that might cause you to worry. You did the right thing, but in this case I think the card should have been returned to PSA.