Just found this on Retrosheets exibition list. (Sorry, crappy quality. However, it confirms the game on Friday 10/20/1871).
Rob M
040797E7-BCA7-4682-A027-F2ADF3F442AF.jpg
Edited -
75B29E84-68C1-4496-8A06-9E68123C01B1.jpg
Edited again. (Dang, I can't get any photo of larger size when uploading with an ipad. Had to go to my computer).
game.jpg