Bought another 1928 Fro Joy #5 and compared it to my existing one. What do y'all think?
The one I just bought is on the right and is smaller than the existing one. Also, my #2 Look Out....card is smaller than my #6 ....Crack Fielder. When I noticed this prior to sending them to BVG, I asked my friend in Maryland about his, and he confirmed his #2 is narrower that his #6:
With the two between the 70's reprints, black light used (the recent card is left center):