Posted By:
steve yawitzI think he's saying that he sold the card as a PSA 3, but the buyer returned the card after learning that the card was once a PSA 1. The seller is now relisting the PSA 3 with an image of the card in its original slab in the listing (in an amazingly rare display of seller forthrightness, might I add).
It looks as though the scratches might have been buffed a bit, but it's hard to say for sure because the scan of the card in its PSA 3 state isn't all that great. If the scratches were simply rubbed down a bit with a cloth, I can't say that bothers me all that much.
And, really, the whole situation elicits nothing more than a shrug. For better or worse, cracking and resubmitting/crossing seems to be as much a part of the hobby as peanuts and Cracker Jack are to the game itself.