Posted By:
John SI could care less whether a card is in a PSA or SGC holder and I understand that people make mistakes. I purchased a small lot of PSA graded '55 Topps All-American football, most in the 4 to 6 range. I felt that the entire group was overgraded on average about two grades (corner creases on 6's, paper loss/scuffing on 4's). The one below is probably the worst, the scuff on Ace's name makes it almost illegible. The centering is horrible (and not qualified) as well.
