[Archive]

Posted By: Ed Hans

Have to agree with the majority here. At this point-no. Morris and Blyleven (and perhaps others) are more deserving. 3,000 strikeouts (if he gets there) would be hard to overlook, however. As to the criteria of 20 win seasons and ERA, we need to put Moose's career in it's proper context. Had he pitched in four man rotations in the 60s or teens, he would have had multiple 20 win seasons and his ERA would have been about a run lower. He also has the intangibles to make it in another capacity (broadcaster, manager, or executive).